Today, I was pondering about something that has been in the back of my mind for years. It's kind of a controversial topic in the church that I have become more confused about it since I left home for college. In my family, we have always made it a point to not watch R-rated movies. I was told growing up that the prophet said not to watch R-rated movies and so I did my best to avoid it. At one point in school, a student teacher in my gym class in high school told us we would watch a R-rated movie and said we were sissies if we didn't want to watch it. In this case, I didn't stand strong and I didn't tell my parents about it. I went ahead and watched it. We watched "Lord of the Flies", and it was rated R mainly due to the language and subject. I didn't feel good watching it at all and felt guilty afterwards. I vowed after that day to never watch an R-rated movie again and it certainly didn't hurt my life up to now.
Though I have made this choice not to watch such movies, I have seen multiple members of the church watch R-rated movies and many of these people are ones that I love and respect dearly. Many of them were people who are diligent members of the church who are faithful in keeping the commandments. This confused me that they would watch R-rated movies especially when the prophet said not do. Therefore, today, I wanted to understand this principle better. This is what I found:
The only prophet that I could find who blatantly said to not watch R-rated movies was President Ezra Taft Benson. The talk he said it in was "To the Youth of the Noble Birthright" in April 1986 where he said to the youth, “The lusts of your eyes.” In our day, what does that expression mean? Movies, television programs, and video recordings that are both suggestive and lewd. Magazines and books that are obscene and pornographic. We
counsel you, young men, not to pollute your minds with such degrading
matter, for the mind through which this filth passes is never the same
afterwards. Don’t see R-rated movies
or vulgar videos or participate in any entertainment that is immoral,
suggestive, or pornographic. Don’t listen to music that is degrading."
This counsel that President Benson gives is very important, especially for young men in the church and I would say it applies to all members of the church, but the focus here is "vulgar videos or .. . entertainment that is immoral, suggestive, or pornographic." I would have to agree that most R-rated movies fit into this category and therefore have such a rating given to them. I have received the argument though that not all R-rated movies are vulgar, immoral, suggestive, or pornographic. I read an article by Orson Scott Card called "Is There an R-rated Movie Commandment?" that I found interesting that was written in response to "The Passion of the Christ" movie. Orson Scott Card is a member of the church and appears to be quite active. He said about the movie, "There is nothing in this film that
appeals to the "lusts of your eyes"; there is nothing "lewd" or "obscene" or
"immoral, suggestive, or pornographic." Quite the contrary. This film inspires you to feel gratitude to the Savior
and love for those that he loved and who loved him. It inspires you with a
dread of and revulsion for Satan and all his ways. It leaves you with a broken
heart and a contrite spirit."
I admit that I looked down on the movie, "The Passion of the Christ" in high school because it was rated R and I had vowed not to see R-rated movies. It came out my junior year and my Christian friends couldn't understand why I didn't want to see the movie. It was R-rated for its graphic, realistic portrayal of the Savior's atonement. I look back and wonder if I should have thought that through a little more. I am not sure whether I want to see this movie, because I have seen movies not so graphic made by the church about the Savior's atonement and left with the same feelings Orson Scott Card described about this movie. After all, to truly portray the Savior's atonement in a film like it truly happened would give it an R rating. There are many parts of the scriptures that are this way.
I also should mention that there are some highly inspiring R-rated movies that I have seen edited such as Glory, Courage Under Fire, and Gladiator. I don't regret seeing these movies at all, but the question I do have is: Would I regret it if I saw these movies unedited? That's the difficult question. And . . . do I want to find out?
Another thing to be aware of his how PG-13 movies have gotten worse and worse over the years. I talked about my experience seeing the R-rated movie Lord of the Flies, but I've seen movies with worse vulgar content than that movie such as The Butterfly Effect, Titanic, Pitch Perfect and many others. Does that mean we should watch them, because the prophet didn't say we shouldn't watch PG-13 movies? To top it all off, TV has some horrible stuff on it too. There are shows out there that people love that have horrible content in them that are vulgar and inappropriate.
I guess my overall approach to things is making sure I know about what kind of content is in a movie before I watch it. Being cautious is worth it to me, because I believe that movies have a larger effect on people than they want to admit. If I watch movies with pornographic material, then I am poisoning my mind with thoughts that push away the spirit and make it very difficult for virtue to garnish my thoughts. If I watch a movie that glorifies violence such as horror movies do the spirit is pushed away and desensitizes me to violence.
Through this blog post I feel like I have discovered the importance of understanding why people may watch certain R-rated movies, but I still have to say that I think it should still be a rarity in our lives. For me, I am afraid if I crossed that line too much I would justify that watching any R-rated movie is okay and before I know it, I've gone too far. To add to that, I repeat the importance of being careful of even PG-13 movies. Ask questions like: What are these movies doing for me? Are they pushing me away from God or desensitizing me to sacred things? I admit that I forget this sometimes when I watch different forms of entertainment.
In the end, the most important thing is coming to Christ, and if my entertainment is part of what takes me away from coming unto Christ, which usually begins in how we think, then I should be more cautious.